Insurance is a tool to mitigate financial risk. However, risk should be uncertain, unplanned, and unexpected. Insurance restores & puts you back to your existing financial status, neither better off nor worst off. That means no one can make a profit from getting insurance claims.
However, the penetration of insurance in India is just 10% and still considered a highly miss-sold product. 95% of the people buy insurance primarily not to protect their risk or fulfill their needs but for investment purpose to generate returns and/or to save taxes. As they fail to quantify their need specifically, they have to rely on the insurance agent's knowledge and get tempted by the future benefit shown to them in a spreadsheet. Buyers fail to calculate the time value of money and thereby compounding benefit, the effect of inflation, and potential losses if had taken pure investment plants separately.
It is always recommended to have your investments and insurance separately. There are n numbers of products/schemes/policies that fall into these segments. The motto should be to get 'sampoorna suraksha' (entire security) via insurance by choosing the following categories.
- Term Plan (TP)
- Health Policy - Medical (HP)
- Critical illness (CI)
- Personal Accidental Plan (PA)
Insurance also serves another purpose, to provide a lifetime annuity post-retirement. No other product is available in India which provides a guaranteed pension for life.
For investments portfolio, the recommended asset allocation categories are :
- FD
- Small Savings Schemes
- Mutual Funds
- Equity Share
- Bonds & Debentures
- Gold
- Real Estate
The problem with investment tools is that people don't keep a long-term vision of 2 - 3 decades and start timing the market, exit from MF in panic, stop their SIP, etc. and fail to create the required corpus. Insurance has an advantage here as a policy is taken for a pretty long term, you are bound to pay the premium every year.
If you are not a disciplined investor and can't maintain consistency in investments, better to go via insurance root. Although return would be low, compounding will play out gradually if appropriate time is given.